Just saw it and…….. I thought it was a mess, not to say it was bad, but it just wasn't that good, it was very incoherent to me. While the other Graybles were random as well, at least it flowed, this didn't at all. Just my opinion, but one so-so episode doesn't ruin an overall great season and show in general.

A- is a bit too high for my taste, I would say B- or C+ cause I definitely enjoyed the new Regular Show episode more (and that was given a B+).

I said it before and I'll say it again: "The depth of his delusion is awe-inspiring" - Squidward after reading Spongebob diary entry of his perceived friendship with him. This quote perfectly describes Ice King's imaginary relationship with PB, and other things as well.

Wah Wah Wah, jezz if I had a quarter for every Season 4 onwards sucks, it's NOT that bad people! Are there bad episodes, well yes, but there are many episode that are actually okay in my book.

That Shadow Demon Magic is powerful stuff, it probably could have made anyone fall in love with a "Walking Love Magnet". 
Also you forgot about the Gladiator Ghosts.

Ice King takes advice from Jay T. Dawgzone, so it can't be him.

Okay then, here's some thoughts that aren't in the blog.
- Jay T. Dawgzone can't be Jake, that book has existed long before Jake was born.
- Anyone notice the "guardian angel" from "Dungeon" make several cameos during PepBut's ritual scene.
- So that hat was used for peacocking, weird………
There!

Well this is an awfully critical review on a fun episode in my opinion, most of it was spend criticizing a character then the actual episode. I say give the staff time to figure out Thomas, I'm sure they already wrote other episodes with him considering most episodes are done by this point.

I wrote an entire blog for this episode, you can read it here: http://adventuretime.wikia….
Cause I'm pretty sure every thought I wrote won't fit here.

Here's Jakey!

Yep, this show loves the 80s, but at least it doesn't hit you over the head with it over and over again like a certain show on FOX coughFamilyGuycough.

This was a fun episode to watch and it made me happy throughout. Personally I would have placed a B or B+, but I understand your reasoning.

Correct! It was from the Spongebob episode "Little Yellow Book", this was when Squidward started reading Spongebob's diary and noted just how deluded Spongebob takes Squidward's "friendliness".
Come to think of it, The Ice King did always seem like a more perverted and psychotic version of Spongebob to me (having the…

I'm starting to think it was a sleuth pun, then again that could be my dirty mind.

This episode was actually pretty decent, it won't please people who don't like Muscle Man, but since I like him, I thought it was good enough. Though the part where Donny G survived did throw me off.

The delusion quote.

You're seriously questioning Adventure Time Logic?

"My on-again-off-again GF Princess Bubblegum?!?"
The depth of his delusion is awe-inspiring.
Bonus points to anyone who knows where I got that line from.

Well now everyone knows what Finn and Jake were doing during the events of BMO Noire. 
PS: Nice callback to the Squirrel from The Duke.

Well according to Cartoon Network's TV schedule:
http://www.cartoonnetwork.c…
If you check on See All Showings for Adventure Time, you'll see Princess Potluck is scheduled for April 22 at 7:30pm.