I don't make the rules. (There are no rules.)

Yes. It was an ABC Family tv movie and it was terrible.

You are also not a country. But seriously, it made less than two million dollars worldwide.

Well, if we're talking LGBT comedies, I loved But I'm A Cheerleader and Mambo Italiano a lot more. AGM has some funny scenes, but it's just too derivative of American Pie without ever really committing to being a direct parody of it. All you need to know about the sequel is that it has Perez Hilton. Horrible flick.…

I think I saw it three times.

Another Gay Movie is TERRIBLE. And as much as I like Pirate Radio, Taking Woodstock or Zack and Miri, I would never put them on a list of The Best since 2000.

Can we somehow turn that into a crossover slashfic?

But Shaun of the Dead at least had a plot.

Okay, that we can agree on. But the general public LOVES that movie.

"Sad Mouse" was my favorite sketch of that season. It's not laugh-out-loud funny, but I still found it hilarious, yet warm and heartfelt.

I don't know what to think about this until I heard George Takei's opinion.

Or instead of doing a Bond set in the 60s starring Henry Cavill, just give us a second Man from UNCLE.

I only know the director's cut, and that was quite decent. I later read what was cut in its theatrical release and it must have been nearly incoherent.

Come on, that's a low blow. The AV Club has some standards.

I don't care for Sideways either, but come on, I thought "funniest" didn't matter for this list?

Okay. Now take it back.

John Goodman. Patrick Warburton. Eartha Kitt.

Both are a lot more comedic than Adventureland.

Nebraska > all Alexander Payne films since Election

Is Adventureland really a comedy or is it a coming-of-age drama with some funny supporting performances by Bill Hader and Kristen Wiig?