I get what you're saying Overtime…but the trans-genre cover of an unlikely pop hit is really all I watch Idol for anymore. Good or bad (and I mostly root for bad.)

No Claire, I wouldn't.

When you don't have talent or good instinct when it comes to song choice…what other card do you have to play?

Here's the thing about Katie for me. Yes, she's young…but her voice isn't. I think it's going to be hard for her to pick a song so that she comes off as "young." It's so rich and mature for someone her age. Contrast her with Haeley - Haeley sounds young…no matter what she sings.

He is devoid of personality…I agree. There doesn't seem to be any emotion coming out of him when he's singing. Just a look-at-me-play-guitar smile and a painfully smooth forehead.

Bowersox?
Anyone know what happened to her? Lose the rest of her teeth? Gout?

When I wrote that last night I had forgotten about his whorish audition.

I don't think it bodes well that John was speaking in his native language.

And it's probably been said before but Casey reminds me of Vaughn from Community.

Tim Urban
looks and talks like "Chad" from Bravo's Million Dollar Listing. They even have the same haircut. It's really scary.

Also…I believe that Sayid lied to Dogen about Locke saying anything first.

Agreed Lone…I was impressed that they offed TWO characters so early in a season that we just met them…or did they?

I got the idea that this was important. Especially when Dogen asked Sayid if he talked to him first.

I base my vote on who does not "throw up their digits" with their fingers when Ryan's telling you the phone number. I don't know why…but I REALLY hate that.

Agreed Erm. By this time…you knew Gokey and Lambert for sure. This year…they all seem strangely the same. Lots of blond girls.

Really South? Man…I should read those nominations a little closer. Thanks for the heads up.

I'm really pulling for
Il Divo for Best Makeup. If Avatar takes that too…I'm gonna be soooo pissed.

Sorry.

My thought was…is Will Smith still considered A-prime?

Same deja vu for me Zombie!