Yeah, I got the impression that this episode was meant to be following "Controlling Interest". I wonder what made them inject last week's episode instead.

I don't find it surprising that Jones didn't follow Neal. He always seems like a by-the-book guy who doesn't improvise. I think, in his mind, being a back-up to a fellow agent was more important than following a CI. However, I'm not sure if the show meant it that way, or if they did that as a convenience for the plot.…

Haha, yes, literally.

I think the best thing in this episode is that the Horseman got a back story and is linked to Ichabod. I think this adds an emotional layer to the show, and transforms the Horseman from a face-less thing into a real adversary, which is more interesting.

Haha, I went through something similar when I was trying to get to a review from a few days ago.

I lol'd at that comment. I think those little comments add charm to this show.

OK, so when you saw the words "good" and "not-so-good", did you also see the words "two types of threads" and the post I was responding to? You chose to take words out of context and analyze them. And, FYI, I see those types of threads sometimes, and I try to avoid them. The other types of threads that you want to…

I think you missed my point. My comment was not about commenters opinions on episodes, or what makes a good or not-so-good episodes. Rather, it was referring to threads when commenters get outraged (or cynical, or whatever) when some disagree with their opinion. Anyone can be "passionate" or "outraged" about…

So, basically, it's the same show with a different cast.

Yeah, it wasn't as bad as I expected. I didn't hate it.

I came here to ask this same question when I couldn't grade shows. Glad it will return.

Wow, seriously? Calm down. No one is judging your opinions. You inferred all that from my above comment? That's amusing, to say the least.

My reaction to this episode is: Um, what?

That scene was hilarious. I kept thinking "Hey, Will, aren't you a freaking teacher?".

This was one of the best episodes so far this season. I didn't see the last twist coming, but there must be a hell of a story there. Also, I'm starting to really like Millie. I didn't hate her before, but I didn't like her that much either.

Two types of threads I find funny. One is when commenters are outraged at a good episode, and the other is when commenters are outraged at negative comments about a not-so-good episode.

Maybe she's lying to him.

Agreed, and she's the best character on this show.

Bad haircut.

This was a hilarious quote because, I think, for the first time he makes a comment where he's right to be amused. It wasn't just a funny reaction of a guy from the past.