C, I didnt really like it and so it gets a C.

Also what makes me worried is that I get the feeling Todd feels like he has to like it and so gives it a high score and then retroactively tries his hardest to find some way to justify it in his review

It was okay, but what worries me is that the writers said it was in their top five favorite episodes ever. It was one of the weaker episodes of the show to me, especially the second half, with that awkward Pierce announcement and anticlimactic ending. I didn't love the concept either, and unlike the first few seasons…

Ive always thought Nolan Gould was a bad actor, but it worked when he was cute and had funny lines as Luke. I don't know what they can possibly do with him now. I cringe when he's on screen which is too bad because he used to be one of my favorite characters.

God…this site was an amazing thing. Why the heck would you guys, and other such sites ruin it? One day after this is posted it's shutting down because of all this attention after months of being awesome.

Anybody think Luke is aging awkwardly? He has a really weirdly shaped face in my opinion

WTF at Manny joining the football team. Isn't he not athletic?

"He's a weird man" in itself made me laugh because of the deadpan delivery, but following it up with "He's like Phil" killed me

I actually really liked this one. As Monsters Inc. as it was, I loved Cam and Mitchell making up the Wiggles song on the spot "There's a man in my bathroom." That was hilarious.

I like it now because they make it obvious he's just an annoyance and no real threat, ever since the wedding episode. He's just a loser.

Am I bad for cringing at Kurt's speech about Finn looking like Superman coming down the hallway in his jacket?

I actually really liked this one a lot.

Sachem kid…?

If that was the case that was the sloppiest way possible of showing it - IE not at all. That could be a whole episode, and shouldn't occur off-screen with no reason for her to think that. That'd be a huge character moment, so why would it be so underplayed?

I really disliked this one which was a major bummer after the awesome premiere. First of all, Leslie was really annoying in this episode…more than usual. I know they were going for that, but Ben really needed a moment like Ann had in Season 4 where she yelled at her for being a steamroller. Ben really needed to stand…

Its always the double interviews that get me. Mitchell always picks at everything Cam says sarcastically. Every single time. Jay does it too sometimes but for me Jay's don't seem as mean-spirited.

I totally agree. It took me till the first commercial break only to say "Why do I hate this episode?"

I actually really like that idea of him checking Jesse's meth and seeing it was higher than his, and having him smile with pride….

I cant tell if this review is sarcastic or not. 

Pratt is taking off for the movie? :(