For a similar reason as @avclub-13d7df3c17502af69aafccc758195f96:disqus , I'm going to go with Firefly.  Carnivale couldn't wrap things up with just one more season.  I only watched the first season of Deadwood and didn't like it enough to continue into S2.

Ah yes, I recently watched that.  It's good, certainly should be in the discussion, but I put it below Firefly and Carnivale personally.  Not sure if there was a plan for future seasons (following the 'freaks' through college?) but it would've been fun to watch the characters grow up.

Ah yes, I recently watched that.  It's good, certainly should be in the discussion, but I put it below Firefly and Carnivale personally.  Not sure if there was a plan for future seasons (following the 'freaks' through college?) but it would've been fun to watch the characters grow up.

Excellent…can't wait for the interview!

Excellent…can't wait for the interview!

I can't remember the timing of everything either, but I believe Knauf's plan was a six-year arc (three acts of two years a piece, so only the first act was ever completed).  With so much potential it's a crime it got canceled when it did.  I think this was a show ahead of its time in that it would've had a much better…

I can't remember the timing of everything either, but I believe Knauf's plan was a six-year arc (three acts of two years a piece, so only the first act was ever completed).  With so much potential it's a crime it got canceled when it did.  I think this was a show ahead of its time in that it would've had a much better…

Todd, thank you so much for covering this show.  I didn't comment as much as I should have but loved reading the recaps.  Carnivale is my all-time favorite show (slightly ahead of the Wire, which I know, blasphemy and so forth) and I hope the reviews encouraged others to watch for the first time.  I still pop in the…

Todd, thank you so much for covering this show.  I didn't comment as much as I should have but loved reading the recaps.  Carnivale is my all-time favorite show (slightly ahead of the Wire, which I know, blasphemy and so forth) and I hope the reviews encouraged others to watch for the first time.  I still pop in the…

Today's fish is trout a'la creme.

Today's fish is trout a'la creme.

This list made my day.  Tough to argue with the 10 episodes listed, keeping in mind this isn't a 10 best list (which would of course have to include Gunmen of the Apocalypse and Polymorph).

This list made my day.  Tough to argue with the 10 episodes listed, keeping in mind this isn't a 10 best list (which would of course have to include Gunmen of the Apocalypse and Polymorph).

I can't remember what regular air smells like.

I can't remember what regular air smells like.

I got your crotch right here!!!

I got your crotch right here!!!

Looks interesting.  Any word on the Misfits S4 start date?  The video won't open in my lowly undeserving country (Canada) and I can't find any other info on it in the interwebs.

Looks interesting.  Any word on the Misfits S4 start date?  The video won't open in my lowly undeserving country (Canada) and I can't find any other info on it in the interwebs.

Six eh?  Ok let's see…um…when a random TV repair guy and a lonely housewife love each other very much…