A "B" episode for me. Like the interactions between Sherlock and Watson in this episode, however, the Andrew tragedy seems a little bit predictable from the very beginning of his appearance in this season. Sad to see Raza Jaffrey finish his work in Elementary, considering he will be very likely not to appear (?) in…

Best of the first three episodes in S2!! So looking forwards to Abbi x Jeremy official 1st date!!

Agreed. This episode is a little bit disappointing. But still a solid "B" for me.

A ultra beautiful episode with a solid A. I really love Joan's reckless move at the evening event, confronting with the baddddd guy. It was really surprising but it feels so right to see the other side of Watson. Everything about the Sherlock/Kitty dynamics in this episode is just PERFECT and really clarifies all the…

OH, Valerie… I'd root for that!!

Ugh…. Coven…. Ugh…. Lowest Bar Setter

Have to point out that the death-after world idea was really quite like sth really annoying from Coven…

Coven finale was just a mess… This is really way better… I like the way that they just concentrate Elsa in the second half of the finale so that they can ensure there's at least 1 accomplished character. (besides Danny?)

I've got to say… I like this one - definitely didn't expect it to be this good. Despite the numerous unfinished/incomplete/dropped-out plots and characters this season, Elsa is really rather highly accomplished regarding the wonderful plots in the finale. Jessica seems to have got a better character here than in…

The Good Wife's the Mad Men in the modern days…. Just extremely elegant…

Maybe a good thing for Cooper? - More time to shoot potential movies?? I don't really know….

Definitely got to have some breaks for Hannah's irritating behavior in the workshop. -> Definitely why we love it.

This is some episode that will trigger the haters to hate even more about Girls and, on the other side, the lovers to love even more about it as well. I freaking love the final scene!!

I love this episode soooooooooooo much… Just cannot forget anything about it after all this time.

OK, I really think this episode is Looking's "Beach House". For me, "Looking" is really too close to another version of "Girls". Anyway, this episode has the vibe that I always love about Looking. B+ is solid for this good setup for Season 2.

I totally agree, Asylum has revealed that they CAN do wayyyyyy BETTER than Coven and Freak Show.

Too many insufficiently explored characters!!

2 gorgeous episodes!! Both deserve the "A"!!

I believe sooooooo!!!!!!!!

Just don't go there…… Just don't quit Iowa like last season with GQ, or it is 90% more likely to be too boring to watch.