Dumb question here, but since you are responding to me I'll ask you. I'm new to commenting and was wondering how I change my profile picture. Any idea?

Yeah I completely agree, although I think season 2 was still pretty good and had a good pay off at the end, and season 3 wasn't bad, in fact it had some great moments. I just think it might have been a premature exit. I can't speak for the 4th season as I haven't watched it yet, but it would be a shame if he regretted…

You should read my post again, I wasn't disagreeing with you, I was agreeing. And while I can name a few movies he's been in recently, I haven't wanted to see them.

I get that he wanted to leave for a film career. But the series is what made him a star and gave him said film career. When you get given your big break its kind of shitty of you to leave when its to the detriment of the story they were telling. If it felt like the natural end of his character arc, then fine, but he…

Hey, he had a 6 minute part in Thor 2 where he was immediately killed by the guy who used to be Doctor Who. So who's the idiot now?

Seriously? I'd rather watch a sub-par Locke or Jack episode than a truly bad episode featuring characters doing nothing of any substance.

I don't know, season 1 was still pretty great. Just little images like Sawyer holding the letter over the lighter, contemplating whether to burn it and choosing not to. Also the use of songs was excellent in season 1.

Yeah that was a great one. It would have been great if they opened every recap with those two scenes even in season 6 just because of how memorable they were.

I could talk for hours on end about the brilliance of Lost, but one personal favourite was the subtle way they first introduced time travel and how it was so rarely focused on it left you craving for more and finally peaked with one of the best episodes ever in The Constant. Sadly time travel would become the dominant…

Absolutely, and can we all agree that 'Expose' was the worst episode the show ever did? A whole ep devoted to characters we hated for all the wrong reasons just to kill them in a wink wink way, but that also retconned awesome stuff like Locke and Ecko discovering the ? hatch. Really, Nikki and Paolo got there a couple…

I took a picture of myself the other day because I was sunburnt and wearing a straw hat. We're all contributing in any way we can.

Am I the only one who every once and a while, completely to himself, just says out loud 'Previously on Lost,' in the exact same accent and tone from the show? Sometimes I'll even start to recite Rousseau's common line in the recap, 'The others are coming. You have only three choices. Run, hide, or die.' That was at…

I might be new to commenting on the AV Club but not new to reading it, which led me to detect a certain amount of sarcasm in your post. However, your picture of Hurley and Jack has thrown me into complete disarray. So to wrap up, if you meant that genuinely, then thanks!

I stopped at Honours so I could get my career going. 18 Months later it's finally starting to almost nearly get kind of going.

As James Randi says, when you get a PhD two things happen. You forget how to say 'I was wrong,' and 'I don't know.'

Absolutely. Or the scene in the same episode where Jack is wandering through the hatch, torch and gun in hand, and all of a sudden a bright light shines on him as 'Make your own kind of music plays.' Such awesome atmosphere and world building.

For all its faults, Lost remains one of my all-time favourite shows. It's the main reason I chose to become a writer, and will always flashback to the thrill I had watching episodes like 'The Man Behind the Curtain' (one of the show's and the third season's best) whenever someone talks about it.

'Eyes that pop out of there head… Steve.'