We're still discussing the show, @avclub-387212ba9644c8b7f3d7178512148235:disqus, moving on to Season 5 this Wednesday, September 9. If you'd still like to comment on Season 4, there's a review for every episode at the end of this comments section. I'd be happy to respond to anything you'd like to add.

We'll be discussing Season 5 starting Wednesday, September 9. I posted a schedule at the end of these comments, basically two episodes a week.

"Will you look at this place! And the price has been slashed repeatedly."

"You know, Homer, I'm starting to realize life is short."

Okay, I do have a theory about Jacob tying into something I've been considering during my rewatch: what if Jacob can see their fates because he's lived this life before? I see a lot of mentions about him being something like 2000 years old (and it's probably true and my theory is completely wrong) but what if he's…

I honestly don't remember what I was thinking when the Island moved, my focus was more on the body in the coffin being Locke. Even though it's so obvious in retrospect, for me, it was more a matter of, "Holy crap, they actually KILLED John Locke." All of the characters on the show, I thought he had the best chance…

I LOVED 316 the last time I watched it, the opening scene is brilliant and it is very cool from beginning to end. I also recall with a lot of interest the Jack and Kate scene in his apartment that morning. That was one of the few moments in Season 5 where they got a chance to briefly relax and just be together. …

Don't say revenge! Don't say revenge!

I like your take on this, for some reason, I never really have considered the compass to be the item that Richard expects him to take. In light of Season 5's time travel, that does make sense because Locke does give it to Richard, who in turn gives it to Locke, who then travels through time so he can give it back to…

I just checked out the link, it's VERY long so I think I'm going to give it a read later when I can take my time with it. As for what you wrote here, I'm going to disagree on the love triangle/quadrangle. While it's definitely true that fans did complain about how that played out, I certainly don't think it was…

The A.V. Club

Suicide Booth: Please select mode of death.

Farnsworth: How did you get this number? Hermes, hang up on him in the rudest possible manner.

Morbo: Scientists believe the rip is a gateway to another universe, but do not know what mysteries lie beyond. However, in this reporter's opinion gruesome death awaits us all!

Yes, Something Nice Back Home is Jack being a "dad" to Aaron. Completely agreed on Lilly, but I keep finding a lot of highlights in her performance. I think people tend to forget she did not have any speaking roles prior to Lost, so as the show was maturing, she was doing the same as Kate.

Top 5 Scenes of Season 4

*****There's No Place Like Home: Another great season finale starts with the Oceanic Six finally arriving back on the mainland. I really noticed this the first time on a rewatch: the shot of Kate looking around and seeing no one there for her, and then the cut back to the Island, where we see her standing near the…

Hey, good to see you again…I'm going to try to post a review for There's No Place Like Home in about 12 hours, and I'll try to respond to your other posts as well.

Hey, I hope you're still checking this page for new comments. I still plan to post for There's No Place Like Home on Wednesday, but it may be a little later than usual. Just not sure if it's worth continuing after that. I'd love to keep posting, but my reviews are not great…I feel like I'm much better at discussing…

The A.V. Club