Ugh! It's like a party in my mouth and everyone's throwing up!

Juliet and Kate's mud fight was actually in Season 3's Left Behind, I don't think they really had a scene together in The Other Woman b/c Juliet was too busy with going after Daniel and Charlotte.

Not that it matters in the grand scheme of things, but I feel that Matthew Fox definitely deserved more than one Emmy nomination for his role (only got the one for Season 6). Surprising that as big as Season 1 was, the only nominees from Lost for acting were Naveen Andrews and Terry O'Quinn. Jack was at his most…

It can get confusing, I'll grant you that…but speaking as someone who enjoys a good list, it sure was fun to speculate over details like that.

What's your answer…?

Regarding the outrigger, I read that eventually they were planning on auctioning off the scene that they had either written out or had in mind for Season 5. So maybe all of us A.V. Clubbers who are Lost fans should try to get in on that and then we'll know this well-kept secret.

I think I may be missing something as well, but last I checked, Jack was on the list that Michael was given in "Three Minutes". Not only that, he was at the top of the list, so unless this discussion is about a different list, I'm not sure what you're talking about.

It's been several months since I watched Season 2 again, but didn't Ben (as Henry Gale) mention Jacob by name when he was in the hatch with Locke? I know that he described him for sure, but I feel like the first mention of Jacob was before this. Once you've seen it all several times though, everything can kind of…

Fry: Bender, I'm alive! You didn't hurt me at all. But I know you wanted to, and that's what matters. Here's to you.

"You're right. I need professional help. And damn the expense."

Wow, sunk like a stone…

I would definitely agree with this, and it's a big reason why Left Behind is not only one of my favorite episodes of Season 3, but of the whole show.

"I'm still on the fence as to whether Kate actually did mean it when she said she loved Sawyer."

Bart, this is your father! Do you know where the remote is? I looked all over the house.

The A.V. Club

Personally not a fan of these on-screen hashtags; Myles mentions The Amazing Race at the beginning, they seem to be fond of using hashtags repeatedly but it just seems to get in the way. I think the majority of the Lost audience would have been annoyed with it, such as Season 6's The Package, when a promo for V…

Watching this scene takes me back to the magic of 2004, it was riveting to watch the Sox first make their miraculous comeback against the Yankees, right around the time Lost was premiering. Those first few episodes were so amazing that I couldn't help flipping back and forth between a repeat of Walkabout and Game 1…

I had forgotten about that line, that's one of his better ones though. Maybe Charlie just expected to have a bunch of groupies on the Island, starting with Kate and Shannon, but when no one really recognized him, it was time to start over. Probably for the best.

The A.V. Club

Don't crack wise with me, tubby.