Judges, and not justices. This is the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, a Federal Appellate Court, not a State Supreme Court. The case argued that the Wisconsin law was so egregious as to violate the voting rights act. The court was split 5-5 on whether to review the legality of the law. That doesn’t involve the…

Incorrect. That was at a motion for en banc review, where the court voted 5-5 on whether to rehear the case in its entirety. Four other judges joined Posner’s opinion regarding the Wisconsin statute. The full record and briefing was available to the court, and Posner cites it pretty extensively. Or did you not…

This is wrong. The assertion is that voter impersonation fraud, the only kind of voter fraud that voter ID laws would prevent, is negligible. In the single digits per election cycle. In contrast, voter ID laws make it incredibly difficult for tens of thousands of individuals to vote. There’s a disconnect here.

Please provide evidence that actual voter fraud exists. And please provide evidence of voter impersonation fraud, the only kind of voter fraud that would actually be remedied by voter id laws.