Gwen Ihnat
gihnat
Gwen Ihnat is the Editorial Coordinator for The A.V. Club.
10/14/19
1:13 PM
3

I am actually incredibly entertained by what’s happening to Noah. He’s such a douchebag; he deserves it! I’m only sad that they’re setting it up to end with he and Helen getting back together, because she absolutely does not deserve that.

10/14/19
9:20 AM
2

Although that episode didn’t explicitly present different POVs in the usual style, it’s possible we were seeing each character’s perspective during their own scenes. Either way... I don’t think “truth” exists on this show. And that’s kind of the point.

10/14/19
2:27 AM
1

Seeing as Helen’s birthday is in Spring - once again the writers have made a mistake.

10/13/19
10:22 PM
4

It could have been an interesting concept doing a storyline on the pitfalls of the Me Too movement, but making Noah Solloway the victim in that scenario (who just four episodes ago was stealing a woman’s bra) is mind-boggling.

10/13/19
10:16 PM
1

I believe that the hurricane episode was the only episode without specific points of view, with it being framed by the time of events rather than each characters perspective. It is entirely possible that what happened that episode was the actual truth of what happened rather than each persons interpretation of what Read more

10/11/19
12:27 AM
1

I’m a little late in the game here, there are so many great shows to watch right now—I can’t keep up. (And before anyone says anything, no this is not one of the great shows I mentioned above.) Just want to say great review Gwen, your observations are spot on! I’ll continue to watch this mess of a show just so I can Read more

10/9/19
2:12 PM
1

You bring up some excellent points. I haven’t been as down on the season as a whole as you have (but damn close, at times) but I couldn’t agree more about just NOT CARING. As much as Joanie says the phrase, it is ME who truly DOESN’T CARE at this point. Read more

10/9/19
1:55 PM
6

True story: My brother and I missed our cousin’s wedding rehearsal in 2007 because we were watching a rerun of that movie on Lifetime.

10/9/19
1:32 PM
34

Why you got to give her a fight?
Can’t you just let it be?

10/8/19
8:49 PM
3

This was literally one of the stupidest episodes of television I’ve seen. The joanie part, that is. The Noah/Whitney section was classic Affair; two damaged and imperfect people being as honest with each other as they can. Then the joanie section just completely went off the rails. Everything was stupid. Decision Read more

10/7/19
8:10 PM
1

Where to start.. ok so I too was confused by the signing of the name. I thought she was clear because of course she signed it as Gabriel.. right? Apparently not. That was a hard pill to swallow. Then his records of her being a patient for the last 3 weeks.. so uh in the future they cant look at Credit card Read more

10/7/19
6:22 PM
3

I’m hoping that just when Noah FINALLY realizes what a douche bag he’s been, it’s far too late to make amends, and all his past shenanigans are going to catch up with him. Read more

10/7/19
9:32 AM
1

Well after last week’s preview I thought this episode would be terrible and at least it wasn’t what I predicted. Still, it was terrible in a different way. Time to take this show out back like old yeller so I can forget this season.